Spotlight on strategic philanthropy – interview with Eric Berseth

All Insights

Currently reading

AI meets academia - interview with Professor Nathan Furr

News & interviews

3 min read

AI meets academia - interview with Professor Nathan Furr

Leading academics Professor Andrea Beltratti, Professor Nathan Furr and Associate Professor Kamiar Mohaddes from three of EFG’s university partners spoke to InTalks about the enduring relevance of universities in a digitalised world and how AI is shaping approaches to teaching and learning. They also explained why their core mission of fostering independent, critical thinking is more important than ever to ensure students can thrive in the AI era.

Marketing & Communications

Marketing & Communications

Professor Nathan Furr
from INSEAD, Fontainebleau

Universities have always been dedicated to the cultivation and transfer of knowledge − this is their raison d’être. With AI now capable of retrieving, summarising and even generating knowledge on demand, do you believe the core purpose or function of a university has shifted?

The purpose of universities is not simply to “transfer” knowledge; it has always been about developing critical thinking and creativity and encouraging the discovery of the unknown. AI is no substitute for this. Indeed, existing research suggests that the use of AI leads to cognitive offloading and a decrease in the critical thinking skills that underpin the thoughtful and creative development of knowledge. Even in cases where the summation capabilities of AI help to uncover unexplored niches of knowledge, the capacity for original judgement that provides a competitive advantage is still what distinguishes great leaders and thinkers.

Where do you see AI’s greatest (and maybe still unrealised) potential to support higher education?

Many years ago at Stanford, before the advent of generative AI, we shifted the focus of engineering education from mastering domains of knowledge to learning to ask the right questions and then connecting different areas of knowledge to answer those questions. This shift from mastering content to mastering problems was driven by the overwhelming growth in knowledge and the realisation that it was no longer effective to train students to master a single domain but rather to focus on critical thinking and problem solving. AI can prove effective in this context by providing a vast pool of knowledge that a truly creative problem solver can draw on to develop a solution.

What do you consider the most underestimated risk or challenge that AI poses to universities? And is the world of academia ready to tackle it?

The greatest risk is clearly that of cognitive offloading ‒ the idea that students offload the hard cognitive work that underpins creative thinking, original judgement and true insight and thus become dependent on AI, which is an “averaging machine”. More than ever, we need to train people to think critically, to challenge the machine and to avoid deferring to data since that data is not always right.

Looking beyond pure subject matter expertise, which core skills will continue to be needed across all disciplines in an AI-driven world?

Innovative thinking, problem solving and great leadership rely on the ability to separate the signal from the noise and then act on it. A critical skill before the advent of generative AI was being a T-shaped thinker with depth of knowledge in one domain but also the ability to think across many other fields. But AI cannot tell you what you should do, nor set the right strategic priorities. Students will need to be able to build on the knowledge and judgement they have developed and to combine it with the right tools and resources to ensure they are well equipped to succeed in the future.

What would you say if a student were to ask you today: “What should I focus on to thrive in this new era?”

Learning and critical thinking. The future has always belonged to those who are willing to learn. I would tell them to use the tools at their disposal but to also put themselves through the paces of grappling with a problem because that is a skill most people are offloading to AI and they will struggle markedly as soon as AI tools fail them – which they inevitably will, since these are probability machines that make errors.

Albert Einstein once famously said: “The only thing you absolutely have to know is the location of the library” − alluding to its role as a gateway to knowledge. How is the importance of major university libraries (including digital libraries) changing in an AI-driven world?

Einstein wasn’t speaking about a building but about the ability to learn and access knowledge. AI can lower the barriers to access some types of knowledge but learning and critical thinking, or the ability to challenge the dominant paradigm, is not something you can outsource to AI.

About

Nathan Furr is a Full Professor of Strategy & Innovation at INSEAD (Fontainebleau). He has a PhD from Stanford University and has published five books and over 70 articles based on his research into how companies innovate, navigate uncertainty and respond to technology disruption. An Innosight Fellow, Nathan Furr has been nominated for multiple “Thinkers 50 Innovation” Awards and works with leading companies to help them reimagine their future. He is also co-founder of the EFG Future Leaders Network, an initiative designed to foster a new generation of adaptable, visionary leaders, and he is a regular speaker at a variety of EFG events.

Required

Required

Required

Required

Required

Required

Required

Please note you can manage your subscriptions by visiting the Preferences link in the emails you receive from us.

Required